Renzo's Pizzeria & Trattoria

Renzo's Pizzeria & Trattoria in Kenosha, WI, is a cherished local gem where authentic Italian flavors come alive in a warm, inviting setting. Specializing in classic Italian fare, this beloved spot offers a diverse menu ranging from freshly made pasta to artisanal pizzas, all crafted with a dedication to homemade quality and rich, comforting taste.

From the moment you step inside, the atmosphere at Renzo’s feels like a friendly neighborhood trattoria with an old-school vibe. You place your order and pay at the welcoming service window, which adds to the casual yet personal experience. Despite occasional understaffing, the service is impressively attentive and brisk, making it easy to feel right at home.

The menu is a treasure trove for lovers of Italian cuisine and pizza aficionados alike. One cannot visit without trying the famed Renzo Fries—crispy, golden, and perfectly seasoned, these fries have become a must-have indulgence that diners rave about. Pasta lovers will find delight in the homemade ravioli stuffed with rich fillings and the luscious fettuccine Alfredo, served with a delicate, creamy sauce that coats every noodle gracefully. While some have noted the Alfredo sauce varies, it remains a standout comfort dish worth savoring.

Pizza enthusiasts are spoiled for choice here. Whether you crave the classic Pepperoni Pizza or prefer something more adventurous like the Spinach Pizza Margherita or Alfredo Pizza, each pie is made with freshly stretched dough and lovingly topped with vibrant ingredients. The regular crust pizzas come in multiple sizes, from personal 9-inch to a generous 20-inch feast, catering perfectly to both solo diners and groups.

For an extra-special treat, the Pizza Turnover Calzone is a personal favorite among patrons—rolled fresh dough enveloping gooey mozzarella and your choice of toppings, then covered with savory sauce. This dish uniquely blends the heartiness of pizza with the satisfying crispness of a turnover, making for a comforting and portable delight. The Mini Pizza Turnover served with a fresh salad is a great option for those dining in and seeking a lighter meal.

Renzo's also shines with its sandwiches. From the hearty Bombers packed with beef, sausage, and meatball, to the versatile Chicken Cotolette sandwich served grilled or fried with crisp lettuce and ripe tomato, there is a sandwich to satisfy every appetite. Extras like American bacon or giardiniera add layers of flavor that elevate the experience.

What truly sets Renzo’s apart is the family-like hospitality that Mama Renzo imparts—a feeling echoed in numerous customer reviews. Regulars like Brooke Gearhart share that dining here feels like coming home, with genuine service and dishes that never disappoint. Customers appreciate the authentic tastes reminiscent of Italy’s culinary heritage, paired with a welcoming ambiance that invites you to slow down and savor your meal.

A quick note to visitors: Renzo’s operates on a cash-only basis and ordering is done upfront. It’s wise to book ahead for larger groups to ensure a smooth and enjoyable visit. Whether you're after a relaxed dinner away from the hustle or craving a peak into traditional Italian flavors, Renzo’s Pizzeria & Trattoria delivers an experience that’s both heartfelt and flavorful.

In every bite, from the first crispy Renzo fry to the last melty stretch of cheese on their stuffed pizza, Renzo’s brings a sincere passion for Italian cuisine that keeps customers returning time and again. It’s more than just a meal—it’s a taste of home and a celebration of authentic Italian comfort food in the heart of Kenosha.